“Sometimes who we are on the outside matches who we are on the inside. But sometimes it doesn’t, and that’s okay.”
Except it’s not ok, apparently. According to girlguiding who have had their hand forced by the law. But have they truly, could we have collectively made a stand?
In 2025, the UK Supreme Court ruled that under the Equality Act 2010, the legal definition of the word "sex" refers specifically to biological sex at birth. Because Girlguiding’s governing charity documents legally restrict its membership and benefits strictly to "girls and women," the Supreme Court's decision meant that "girls and women" must legally be interpreted as those recorded female at birth
But documents could be changed, the world changes and we have been growing together learning that anyone can be who they want to be.
I’m seeing friends leaving guiding because they are prepared to take a stand for what they know to be right. I’m torn, I am aware this country is sleep walking back to a time of bigotry and hate. For many that never went away, it’s their way of life to hate those different to them, to assume trans are a risk because they don’t understand them, to feel threatened by them because it challenges how they see sexuality.
Almongst all this I know there are many girls that still need girlguiding and everything we give them. The experiences, the development, the future. From the inside I can continue to express my belief of tolerance and understanding for all…or am I just trying to self justify still belonging to an organisation that can’t be open.
We manage residentials now that include both sexes, we safeguard all, we don’t have one to one situations, exactly what is the problem with trans girls and women members?
As I say, I sit on a very uncomfortable fence.
Here’s a thing: it’s polite to call people in a manner they like to be referred as, it won’t hurt you to try to do that. Who other people choose to love doesn’t affect you, leave them to be happy, look in a mirror if them being happy upsets you. What clothes people choose to wear is up to them, you don’t need to worry about it. 🌈
I’m so unhappy to see my guiding friends hurt over this, and I’m so proud of them for taking the choices they are. I’m not sure I will ever stand so proud at Pride ever again knowing we let people down, we pushed them out. That’s not ok.
“Sometimes who we are on the outside matches who we are on the inside. But sometimes it doesn’t, and that’s okay.”
Read more...